I violate impartiality if I combine these beliefs:
I violate impartiality if I combine these beliefs:
Impartiality requires that we make similar evaluations ABOUT SIMILAR ACTIONS. The example says nothing about the actions being (exactly or relevantly) similar.
Maybe it's right for me to perform appendix operations, but wrong for you, because I'm a trained doctor but you aren't. There's no inconsistency in holding this.
I violate impartiality if I combine these beliefs:
Impartiality requires that we make similar evaluations ABOUT SIMILAR ACTIONS. The example says nothing about the actions being (exactly or relevantly) similar.
Maybe it's right for me to perform appendix operations, but wrong for you, because I'm a trained doctor but you aren't. There's no inconsistency in holding this.